Kayla portrayed the role of Barbara in boom, a UPStages Student Lab production. The show was directed by John Michnya, a doctoral student at the university.
Company marked Kayla's first Sondheim, as well as her first production at the University. She relished the role of Joanne, especially as it will be several decades until she is qualified to play it again. The Pitt Musical Theatre Club produced Company in the Spring 2013 Semester. The show was directed by Shannon Knapp, who is currently working as one of the artistic directors and founders of Alarum Theatre.
Kayla portrayed Sarah in the 2010 World Premiere of Facefull: The World's First Social Networking Musical. The book and score were composed by her father, Michael Martine, who also directed. The show performed at the Susquehanna Stage Company in Marrietta, PA.